Vacations in the mountains: When the airplane turns out to be more affordable than the train, a surprising situation

When thinking of ski holidays, snow-covered mountains and ski slopes immediately come to mind. However, one often overlooked aspect of organizing a mountain getaway is transportation. Why is the plane, generally perceived as a costly and polluting option, sometimes found to be more economical than the train for reaching ski resorts? This article explores this unexpected situation that could change the way you view your upcoming travels for a ski holiday.

A majority of holidaymakers on the road

Most winter sports enthusiasts choose to arrive at their destination by car. According to recent statistics, nearly 90% of tourists access the ski resorts of the Savoie region by personal vehicle, or in combination with a flight. This mode of transport, while pleasant for visiting alpine landscapes, has a significant impact on the carbon footprint of these trips. It is therefore legitimate to question the alternatives available, particularly the train.

The train, an ecological choice but sometimes costly

Although the train remains a more environmentally friendly means of transport (emitting up to 10 times less CO₂ per kilometer than a car), it is often perceived as a financially less viable option. Train tickets, for certain routes, can reach prices significantly higher than plane tickets. Why this cost disparity? Indeed, rail services do not always benefit from the necessary investments to ensure attractive pricing, unlike airlines that regularly offer promotions.

Accessible flights: A whole different reality

Many airlines, particularly low-cost carriers, offer discounted fares to reach destinations with ski resorts. It is not uncommon to find plane tickets at unbeatable prices, especially outside peak periods. In comparison, the train, despite its environmental advantages, remains sometimes an unaffordable luxury. Direct flights to airports near the resorts provide a quick and efficient solution, without the hassles associated with driving on mountain roads.

A call for reassessment of transport by authorities

In light of this reality, the president of the National Association of Mayors of Mountain Resorts, Jean-Luc Boch, calls for a development of rail services. He emphasizes the importance of making the train accessible and attractive for holidaymakers and advocates for a return of night trains, which allowed travel without losing a day. By rethinking customer service and profitability, SNCF could encourage more holidaymakers to take the train instead of the road.

A future to rethink for ski holidays

As the ski season approaches, holidaymakers are urged to reflect on their transport choices. The plane, although criticized for its carbon footprint, can sometimes prove to be a financially advantageous option. Meanwhile, the need for an improved train service could not only reduce the carbon footprint of the journeys but also enhance the travel experience. Urging authorities to consider creative and sustainable solutions could transform the future of ski holidays.